Per un punto di vista diametralmente opposto (con un linguaggio,
però,
a tratti francamente poco dignitoso), vedere:
http://3dblogger.typepad.com/wired_state/2013/01/james-boyle-vs-orin-kerr-on-swartz.html
jc
Aaron's Army
Memorial for Aaron Swartz at the Internet Archive
January 24, 2013
TEXT OF REMARKS BY CARL MALAMUD
Do not think for a moment that Aaron's work on JSTOR was the random
act of a lone hacker, some kind of crazy, spur-of-the-moment bulk
download.
JSTOR had long come in for withering criticism from the net. Larry
Lessig called JSTOR a moral outrage in a talk and I suppose I have
to confess he was quoting me. We weren't the only ones fanning those
flames.
Sequestering knowledge behind pay walls—making scientific journals
only available to a few kids fortunate enough to be at fancy
universities and charging $20 an article for the remaining 99% of
us—was a festering wound. It offended many people.
It embarrassed many who wrote those articles that their work had
become somebody's profit margin, a members-only country club of
knowledge.
Many of us helped fan those flames. Many of us feel guilty today for
fanning those flames.
But JSTOR was just one of many battles. They tried to paint Aaron as
some kind of lone-wolf hacker, a young terrorist who went on a crazy
IP killing spree that caused $92 million in damages.
Aaron wasn't a lone wolf, he was part of an army, and I had the
honor of serving with him for a decade. You have heard many things
about his remarkable life, but I want to focus tonight on just one.
Aaron was part of an army of citizens that believes democracy only
works when the citizenry are informed, when we know about our
rights—and our obligations. An army that believes we must make
justice and knowledge available to all—not just the well born or
those that have grabbed the reigns of power—so that we may govern
ourselves more wisely.
He was part of an army of citizens that rejects kings and generals
and believes in rough consensus and running code.
[...]
Continua qui: https://public.resource.org/aaron/army/