*"Surveillance Without Borders? The Unlawfulness of the NSA-Panopticon, Part I"** * Published on November 1, 2013 <http://www.ejiltalk.org/surveillance-without-borders-the-unlawfulness-of-the...> Author: Anne Peters <http://www.ejiltalk.org/author/anne-peters/> *Introduction: The draft GA resolution on privacy on the Internet* At the end of October 2013, a draft General Assembly resolution <http://statewatch.org/news/2013/oct/un-draft-resolution-on-privacy-us-survei...> calling for the right to privacy on the Internet was sponsored by Brazil and Germany. /(photo: a panopticon <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panopticon>, credit <http://filosofie.be/blog/de-neo-cynicus/2378/ter-info-wat-is-een-panopticum-en-hoe-werkt-het/>)/ The draft resolution reaffirms the human right to privacy. It calls upon states to take measures to put an end to violations of these rights (operative para. 4 b), calls upon states to review their procedures, practices and legislation concerning the extra-territorial surveillance of private communications (para. 4 b) and calls upon states to establish independent oversight mechanisms capable of ensuring the transparency and accountability of state surveillance of communications (para. 4 d). Although the draft resolution does not mention the United States or the National Security Agency (NSA), it is indirectly reacting against the NSA's recent espionage and surveillance activities conducted in a number of European states, including France, Italy, and Spain. This two-part post will focus on surveillance of German officials including the chancellor Angela Merkel and of ordinary persons in Germany by way of example. Spying on government officials concerns general international law, which will be the focus of Part I of this post. Part II will focus on the bugging of the communication of private persons, which implicates human rights law. *Breach of international law vis-à-vis the surveilled states* The interception of communication by government officials, agents, and authorities seems to constitute espionage. However, there are no specific international law norms that would contain or regulate espionage. [...] Continua qui: http://www.ejiltalk.org/surveillance-without-borders-the-unlawfulness-of-the...