Ognuno per la sua strada. Il Covid-19 ringrazia. Chiarimento sui rapporti tra DP-3T e PEPP-PT DP-3T is a free-standing effort, originally started at EPFL and ETHZ, that has now broadened out to include stakeholders from across Europe and beyond. We develop the protocol and implement it in an open-sourced app and server on this repository. DP-3T members have been participating in the loose umbrella of the 'Pan-European Privacy-Preserving Proximity Tracing' (PEPP-PT) project. DP-3T is not the only protocol under this umbrella. PEPP-PT also endorses centralized approaches with very different privacy properties. Pandemics do not respect borders, so there is substantial value in PEPP-PT's role of encouraging dialogue, knowledge-sharing, and interoperability. Nevertheless, as the systems endorsed by PEPP-PT have technical differences that yield very different privacy properties, it is a mistake to use the term 'PEPP-PT' to describe a specific solution or to refer to PEPP-PT as if it embodies a single approach rather than several very different ones. —
On 21 Apr 2020, at 08:43, Giovanni Biscuolo <giovanni@biscuolo.net> wrote:
Buongiorno,
AFAIU ROBERT è l'alternativa a DP-3T dopo che gli ultimi sono stati buttati fuori da PEPP-PT, e questo dice tutto su ROBERT.
Con tutto il rispetto per le persone coinvolte, mi pare che anche l'accademia non stia proprio dando il meglio di sè.
Giuseppe Attardi <attardi@di.unipi.it> writes:
Pessima idea quella di centralizzare tutti i dati per calcolare un punteggio di rischio personalizzato.
...e cattivo gusto prendere per i fondelli le persone con convoluzioni celebrali tipo
--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
“All systems in the works include a common component (a server) and a decentralized component (a group of smartphones that can communicate between them using Bluetooth): all systems currently in the works are therefore both centralized […] and decentralized,” he continued.
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---
«centralized-decentralized contact-tracing protocol.», è scritto nero su bianco :-O
Faccio fatica a credere che queste parole siano uscite dal CEO di Inria.
Saluti. Giovanni
-- Giovanni Biscuolo